North Carolina Seafood Tour Part 2: Crystal Coast

  • By Sandy Lang
  • Photography by Peter Frank Edwards
  • Illustration by Joseph Edwards

This stretch of our North Carolina Seafood Tour takes you from Swansboro to Cedar Island, and makes five mouthwatering stops along the 75 mile-route.

Along the saltwater edge of North Carolina, we have seafood. It’s in shacks, in stores, in dining rooms. It’s everywhere. There’s no way we could get to it all, but we tried. We sent a writer and a photographer on a three-part, south-to-north drive that took them on beach roads and ferries and fishing piers. They traveled 250 miles. And everywhere along the way, they ate.
  1. Clyde Phillips Seafood Market

    The second drive begins on a weekday afternoon at Clyde Phillips Seafood Market (est. 1954), between the bridges on the causeway in Swansboro. Shrimp boats are tied up at the dock behind the store. Inside a small fish house with concrete floors, fishermen recall better days when the catch might include red drum “with scales big enough to be guitar picks.” Near the sink behind owner Jimmy Phillips, an employee heads a couple of pounds of the shrimp that they still have, and then counts out four dozen littleneck clams for a customer. It’s the end of the day, and the men don’t seem to be in a hurry to leave — a couple of them talk about having a fish fry in the parking lot, this week or next.

    104 East Corbett Avenue
    Swansboro, N.C. 28584

  1. Chefs 105 Restaurant

    We continue up N.C. Highway 24 to Morehead City, looking for oysters on the half shell, and Chefs 105 Restaurant has them. This restaurant opened in 2007 in a circa-1929 building downtown and dedicates a large part of its dining space to the 105 Oyster Bar. We sample a dozen Bogue Sound oysters on ice, and then a half-dozen roasted oysters, hot from the restaurant’s wood-fired oven. One more round of the salty oysters would have been enough for a meal, but we drive on to Beaufort.

    105 South Seventh Street
    Morehead City, N.C. 28557

  1. Royal James Cafe

    On Turner Street, almost to the waterfront, we stop in at the Royal James Cafe just in time to watch two men who are deep into a game at one of the slate-top pool tables. The cook has already gone home for the night, but the bartender says she can get an order of steamed shrimp going: “A local shrimper brought some in today.” She heats a batch of the shrimp in the microwave behind the bar. The peel-and-eat results — seasoned well with Old Bay — are good. And when the bartender explains that the cafe is best known for its freshly ground hamburgers fixed “all the way” with mustard and chili, we order one of those, too.

    117 Turner Street
    Beaufort, N.C. 28516

  1. Sea Side Galley

    The next morning in Beaufort is peaceful, with mirror-flat water around the crab boats and polished teakwood yachts of Taylor’s Creek. Dolphins break the water. Our drive begins on the islands and waterways of Carteret County. We follow U.S. Highway 70 out of town and take Harkers Island Road to our next destination, about 15 miles away.
    The Sea Side Galley’s cafe connects to a convenience store and gift shop that the Guthrie family of Harkers Island opened in 1986. The Core Sound Chowder is a specialty, served by the cup or bowl. Made with a thin broth (no cream or milk), wild clams, and chunks of potato, this version is simple. You can taste the clams. Mila Guthrie, the manager, says the island’s fishermen provide local seafood for the menu throughout the year. “We hear from the fishermen when they’re catching fish,” she says.

    311 Island Road
    Harkers Island, N.C. 28531

  1. Quality Seafood

    Post-chowder, we drive another 32 miles over causeways and past woods, creeks, and a few skiffs, and continue on to the end of the road, literally, at Cedar Island. Near the ferry landing is Quality Seafood, where we catch up with Bradley Styron at his fish house that backs up to Cedar Island Bay. He wears white boots and has just stepped out onto the docks. An enclosed pond where he raises flounder for the sushi market is just across the creek. We’d like to stay and talk more about the fish trade, but the next ferry for Ocracoke Island is about to chug off.

    2890 Cedar Island Road
    Cedar Island, N.C. 28520

A fan of seafood and road trips, writer Sandy Lang is based in Charleston, South Carolina, and she’s a contributing editor for Charleston Magazine and Maine magazine. Her most recent story for Our State was “Gimme Some Sugar” (February 2012).

Follow the rest of the Seafood Tour:
North Carolina Seafood Tour Part 1: Southern Coast
North Carolina Seafood Tour Part 3: Outer Banks

Our State

About Our State

Since 1933, Our State has shared stories about North Carolina with readers both in state and around the world. We celebrate the people and places that make this state great. From the mountains to the coast, we feature North Carolina travel, history, food, and beautiful scenic photography.
This entry was posted in Coast, Dining, May 2012 and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to North Carolina Seafood Tour Part 2: Crystal Coast

  1. Pat Stewart says:

    I, too, was disappointed in this Tour 2. If someone were not familiar with Morehead City/Beaufort, they would really learn nothing about the great places to eat. How can you leave out the legendary Sanitary in MC and the Net House and The Beaufort Grocery
    Co. in Beaufort.

  2. JB says:

    I was disappointed in this supposed tour of Crystal Coast seafood…little seafood was involved and no real seafood restaurants were involved although I know this area has some excellent ones. The seafood markets, while good ones, leave out a lot of other really good markets. The person who wrote this obviously is not familiar with this area’s seafood restaurant or market heritage.

  3. LS says:

    This article said virtually nothing about where to eat great seafood. What a disappointment! Mircro-waved shrimp, hamburger, soup – where’s the seafood meal? Try again fellas.

  4. Pingback: North Carolina Seafood Tour Part 1: Southern Coast | Our State Magazine

  5. Pingback: North Carolina Seafood Tour Part 3: Outer Banks | Our State Magazine

Leave a Comment:

Comments are moderated and once approved will appear in the space above. Your name will appear as you provide it in the block below. Your email address will not appear or be shared. Required fields are marked *.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>