Four for the Road
Bypass the interstate eateries. Try these casual mountain restaurants.
By Susan Hance

photograph by Tim Robison
Caro-Mi Dining Room — Tryon
Just inside the screen door of Caro-Mi Dining Room, owner Dane Stafford greets customers with a smile and a menu.
Located in Tryon on the Pacolet River, Caro-Mi Dining Room has played host to generations of travelers.
If you’re wondering how the restaurant got its unusual name, Stafford says the original owners, the Mahafeys, who moved up from Miami in 1945, created the name by combining Carolina and Miami.
When Stafford’s parents, Charles and Annette Stafford, bought the place in 1990, a portion of the sales contract detailed the restaurant’s top-secret coleslaw recipe. Don’t even try to pry it out of Stafford — he can’t tell you — but the first bite offers a tangy, vinegary clue.
Other menu highlights include the rainbow trout, filleted, boned, and drenched in butter with sliced almonds — a presentation prepared right at the table before serving. And the homemade biscuits? They’re just waiting for smooth apple butter.
Caro-Mi Dining Room
3231 U.S. Highway 176
Tryon, NC 28782
(828) 859-5200
caro-mi.com

photograph by Tim Robison
The Pisgah Inn Restaurant — Brevard
Part of the intrigue of driving up the Blue Ridge Parkway rests in being a part of the mountain itself, blue hills standing watch in the distance and nothing but nature all around — except at mile marker 408.6 north of Brevard. That’s where the Pisgah Inn Restaurant reaches out to capture a stunning view at 5,000 feet.
Windows line every wall of the restaurant, so nothing is shut out, and quilts decorate the ceilings and walls, adding to the Appalachian aura. “We don’t bet on the view,” says owner Bruce O’Connell, whose family has owned the Inn since 1978. Staff members bake the bread; make their own dessert; and offer fresh vegetables, fresh trout, and fresh-cut meats.
Lunch and dinner menus often begin with fried dill pickles, Southern corn fritters, and fried green tomatoes. Reliable favorites like country ham, mountain fried chicken, meatloaf, and chicken potpie continue to please.
Locals and out-of-towners come back year after year during open season from April 1 to October 31. “Pisgahteers,” as some call themselves, use any excuse to savor some old favorites.
Pisgah Inn Restaurant
MP 408.6 on the Blue Ridge Parkway
Brevard, NC 28712
(828) 235-8228
pisgahinn.com

photograph by Tim Robison
Famous Louise’s Rock House Restaurant — Linville Falls
“We make everything from scratch,” says Shirley Yager, whose family has owned Famous Louise’s Rock House Restaurant for more than 30 years. (Shirley is Louise Henson’s daughter.) “The other day I made 98 jars of jam.” Her high-energy voice speeds through the list of jams and jellies she makes. Whatever is in season: blueberry, strawberry, peach, and the legendary strawberry-rhubarb. On a whim, she made pineapple jam one day, thinking it wouldn’t do well, but it, too, became a hit.
In the middle of the road where U.S. Highway 221 North intersects N.C. Highway 183, the sand-colored rock building sits smack in the middle of three counties. You can eat in McDowell County, use the bathroom in Burke County, and pay the bill in Avery County. Built in 1936, the building — originally known as the Linville Falls Tavern — sports a plaque from the National Register of Historic Places.
Besides Yager’s jams, patrons stop in for everything from baby back ribs to steaks and seafood. And dessert, like scratch-made strawberry-rhubarb pie, is simply delicious.
Famous Louise’s Rock House Restaurant
23175 Linville Falls Highway
Linville Falls, NC 28647
(828) 765-2702

photograph by Tim Robison
Helen’s Restaurant — Bakersville
In Mitchell County, you’re bound to get hungry from shopping the art galleries and pottery studios. So as you pass through Loafer’s Glory going up N.C. Highway 226, start looking on the right for Helen’s. A red sign with white lettering on the storefront, plants hanging outside, and a round table for outside dining will clue you in. The restaurant has been there for more than 60 years, so anyone can direct you if you ask.
Long known for hamburgers and hot dogs, Helen’s morphed into a breakfast, lunch, and dinner place with seafood and vegetables when Tom and Glenda Meeler bought it three years ago. But the Meelers have let changes come gradually. The restaurant looks the same inside with original booths, lights, and red-topped counter stools. The old favorites keep a place on the menu, but Glenda has added a few new things.
The “Minnie Pearl burger,” with homemade Thousand Island dressing, slices of Vidalia onion, cheese, and a fried green tomato, is one of her inventions for burger of the week. The “Route 66 burger,” with homemade pimento cheese and fried jalapeno chips, is another of her creations.
A specials menu each day includes home-style dishes such as pinto beans, cornbread, and onions. The “soup beans,” as your grandmother may have called them, are the real deal. Cooked long, but not mushy, and not too dry, they have plenty of liquid to soak the corn bread. It’s just the type of family food that makes you feel like you’ve come home.
Helen’s Restaurant
99 North 226 Highway
Bakersville, NC 28705
(828) 688-9999